Ben Symons/PeacockWe Included these products from Kaylor Martin because we think you’ll like her picks. Kaylor is a paid spokesperson for the Amazon Influencer Program. Our writers and editors independently determine what we cover and recommend. When you buy through our links, E! may earn a commission. Some brands featured in this article are partners of Amazon’s Creator Connections program, which means E! may make an increased commission on your purchase if you buy something through our links. Learn more.
If you watched Love Island USA Season 6, then you know Kaylor Martin went through plenty of ups and downs. Whether navigating her relationship journey or dealing with emotional moments, it was tough for fans to watch her go through it all.
There’s one thing we can all agree on, though: no matter how much she cried, how humid the weather was, or how intense things got, Kaylor’s cry-proof makeup never budged. Fans couldn’t help but wonder—how did she do it?
Well, she finally spilled the secrets. In a recent Amazon Live session, Kaylor shared her best cry-proof makeup hacks and the long-lasting products she swears by. She even revealed her go-to lip combo, featuring affordable beauty finds that her friends always borrow.
Want to keep your makeup looking put-together—no matter what life throws your way? Here’s everything Kaylor swears by to keep it all in place.
Kaylor Martin Lip Combo
“Everyone asks me all the time what I use on my lips. I cannot leave the house without this. I love a dark liner and a pink lip. It never lets you down. This is what I use every day. I swear by this stuff.”
NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
“This is my holy grail. It is so good. All of my friends steal this whenever I am using it and I always have to get more. Once you try this, you won’t go back to any other lip gloss.”
More from Kaylor: “This shade is Tiramisu.”
More Celebrity Fans: Kyle Richards, Charity Lawson
Customer Ratings: 84,400+ 5-star Amazon reviews
NYX Professional Makeup Slim Lip Pencil
“I always do a brown liner. This pencil is in the shade Espresso. This is giving 90s and I am so here for it.”
More Celebrity Fans: Olivia Culpo, Gia Giudice, KyleRichards, and Kyle’s daughter PortiaUmansky.
Customer Ratings: 32,600+ 5-star Amazon reviews
Kaylor Martin’s Cry-Proof Makeup from Love Island USA
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Waterproof Setting Spray
“You guys saw me cry all summer on television, and if you’re wondering why none of my makeup smeared this is why. Thanks, Charlotte.”
More from Kaylor: “I am absolutely obsessed with this. This is amazing. This holds, baby.”
More Celebrity Fans: Melissa Gorga, Olivia Culpo, Paige DeSorbo, Kyle Richards, Rachel Recchia, Lisa Rinna, Emily Simpson, Kristin Juszczyk, Marianna Hewitt, Gia Giudice, Kelcey Wetterberg, and Nordstrom National Beauty Director Autumne West.
Customer Ratings: 2,800+ 5-star Amazon reviews
KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner Vegan Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
“I use this liner. People are like, ‘You cried all last summer and your eyeliner never ran,’ and it’s because of this. Amazing. It’s fire.”
More Celebrity Fans: Victoria Justice
I-envy by Kiss Super Strong Hold Eyelash Adhesive
“I use this glue. It has a super strong hold. This is absolutely amazing. Your lashes will stick and not move at all. This is what I used all summer.”
Customer Ratings: 19,000+ 5-star Amazon reviews
Kiss Blowout False Eyelashes- Pompadour
“This is what everyone asked about. ‘Tell me your lash routine.’ This is what I used every single day. If I were on a desert island, I would want these bad boys with me every single day. I cannot live without these.”
More from Kaylor: “These are my babies. I am obsessed with them. If I could pick one thing out of my makeup routine to keep, it would be these. These help me out so much.”
Customer Ratings: 20,200+ 5-star Amazon reviews
Drunk Elephant D-Bronzi Anti Pollution Sunshine Drops
“I use this every single day before I start my makeup. I prep my face with moisturizer and the Drunk Elephant bronze drops. These are fire. It has been viral for years now.”
More from Kaylor: “No one knows this, but I would put this on my face to go to bed in the villa because I didn’t want anyone to see my pale face. I was embarrassed, going to bed with a pale face because we were on camera.”
More Celebrity Fans: JoJo Fletcher
Customer Ratings: 3,500+ 5-star Amazon reviews
More Kaylor Martin Beauty Essentials
Gecomo Hydrating Lip Glow Oil
“You guys all know the Christian Dior Lip Oil. This is a dupe for it. I’m not spending that much money on a lipgloss that I’m just going to lose. I love this for hydrating.”
Wet Brush Detangling Brush
“Any Wet Brush is amazing. My hair is in terrible shape from using heat on it every single day, and this does not rip my hair out. Anytime I curl my hair, I always brush it out with my Wet Brush.”
More Celebrity Fans: Olivia Culpo, Kenya Moore, Madison LeCroy, Kecley Wetterberg, Katie Austin.
Customer Ratings: 58,000+ 5-star Amazon reviews
Paul Mitchell Pro Tools Express Ion Unclipped 3-in-1 Ceramic Interchangeable Curling Wand
“Whenever I curl my hair with this device, it will stay for like five days— if it’s not raining and humid outside.”
More from Kaylor: “This wand is so great. It has different attachments for you guys to use.”
IGK Good Behavior Spirulina Protein Smoothing Spray Keratin Like Treatment + Frizz Control + Heat Protectant
“This is what I use as my heat protectant, but it has so many hair benefits. This smells like candy. It smells amazing and it helps with frizz.”
Customer Ratings: 4,400+ 5-star Amazon reviews
Dossier Ambery Saffron Inspired by Baccarat Rouge 540
“This one is Ambery Saffron and I believe this is inspired by Baccarat Rouge, but it’s just not $400.”
More from Kaylor: “If you want to smell like a little snack, you need to go and get this. I use this in college and high school as well. This is amazing. You need to try it. It stays just like Baccarat.”
Dossier Floral Marshmallow Inspired by By Kilian’s Love, Don’t Be Shy
“This one is Floral Marshmallow. Absolutely amazing. This is inspired by Kilian’s Love, Don’t Be Shy, which is usually $300 or $400.”
Olaplex No. 7 Bonding Oil
“My hair is so dry. This Olaplex oil helps me because I am a fake blonde, clearly. These bleach and tones are ruining my hair.”
More from Kaylor: “I would say to use this like three times a week.”
More Celebrity Fans: Jenn Tran
Customer Ratings: 43,300+ 5-star Amazon reviews
Laura Mercier Translucent Loose Setting Powder
“I use the Laura Mercier baking powder and I adore it.”
Customer Ratings: 1,900+ 5-star Amazon reviews
Hourglass Vanish Airbrush Concealer
“This is the Hourglass concealer. I’m telling you that this concealer sticks on your face for days. A little bit of this stuff goes such a long way.”
Benefit Fluff Up Brow Wax
“This is amazing in clear.”
Beauty Beautyblender
“I blend with a BeautyBlender normally.”
Customer Ratings: 14,600+ 5-star Amazon reviews
Tarte Lights Camera Lashes 4-in-1 Mascara
“Tarte has the best mascaras. This is my favorite. I use the shade black. I wear mascara over lashes.”
E.l.f. Liquid Bronzer & Contour Duo Brush
Kaylor used this brush to blend her blush.
Patrick Ta Major Headlines Double-Take Creme & Powder Blush She’s Baked
“This blush brings my makeup routine together. It’s fire. The color is She’s Baked.”
Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez Soft Pinch Liquid Blush
“Y’all know that this is amazing. This is in the color Encourage. It’s a mauve color, such a cute color.”
Haus Labs Triclone Skin Tech Foundation
“This is the absolute best foundation. Holy Grail. Swear by it. I won’t use anything else.”
More from Kaylor: “This is by Lady Gaga, the queen herself.”
If you want to do more celeb-approved shopping, you’ll love these picks from MadisonLeCroy, CiaraMiller, KyleRichards, and KandiBurruss.
How We Choose
The E! Insider Shop editors and writers search the internet to find the best products out there. We interview expert sources, comb through customer reviews, and use our own personal experiences to make shopping easier for our readers.
As an editorial team, we independently create content and determine coverage based on research, reporting and what we think our readers would like to read about. The goal of our content is to provide a service and inform readers who are on the hunt for the latest products to help make their life better. Items are sold by retailer, not E!. Pricing and availability are accurate as of publish time.
