One Vanderpump Rules alum’s stint on The Masked Singer was not “Good as Gold.”
Bat was eliminated during the Fox reality competition series’ March 5 episode during “Voices of Olympus: Unmasking of the Gods” night after performing a rendition of Sabrina Carpenter‘s earworm “Espresso.”
But prior to belting out the Grammy-winner’s pop song, the mystery celebrity teased the judges and viewers with some hints about their true identity.
“I’m becoming bat because I’m a creature of the night and a bit of a bat-ass,” she shared in a video package. “Like bats, I’m one of the most misunderstood creatures ever. I’ve been forever villainized, constantly portrayed as a blood-sucking backstabber. And to that I say, ‘Ew! Get over it. I am so not that bat.'”
Bat continued, “My real friends know I actually have a heart of gold. I’ve just been surrounded by a bunch of lunatics and for years all my words have been twisted upside down. I’m just out here partying and having the time of my life, girl, which is why I’m leaning into Dionysus, the god of partying, to show there’s nothing wrong with letting your hair down.”
After her performance, the star revealed her surprising connections to judge Jenny McCarthy and host Nick Cannon.
“It’s been a minute since I’ve seen you, Jenny,” Bat said coyly, adding, “You too, Nick. We actually spent a holiday together this year.”
When it came to the judges’ guesses, Jenny immediately picked Real Housewives of Miami star Larsa Pippen while Ken Jeong also chose a Bravolebrity by guessing Real Housewives of Beverly Hills alum Lisa Rinna. Meanwhile, Rita Ora stayed in the reality TV world by picking Kristin Cavallari, and Robin Thicke followed suit with another ex-Housewife, Bethenny Frankel.
However, none of them correctly guessed that the former SUR-ver under the Bat mask was longtime VPR star Scheana Shay.
“Good to see you, it was Easter,” Scheana told Nick of the holiday they spent together. “We were at the L.A. Mission, serving food.”
The “Good as Gold” singer went on to explain her connection to her costume.
“Bats are one of my favorite animals ever,” she added. “My daughter’s name is Summer Moon—bats are nocturnal. We’ve got a V on me for Vanderpump Rules.”
As for how she thinks her daughter will react to her unmasking? Scheana quipped, “I hope she’s no longer afraid of bats.”
Scheana marks the second VPR castmember to compete on the show, as Tom Sandoval was revealed as season 10’s The Diver in 2023.
Keep reading to meet the season 13 cast and see which other stars have been unmasked so far.
The Masked Singer airs Wednesdays at 8 p.m. on Fox.
Honey Pot: Eliminated Week 1
The sticky and sweet character, who was revealed to be iconic comedian Cedric the Entertainer, was sent home on the season premiere.
Fuzzy Peas: Eliminated Week 2
The verdant vegetable was none other than boxing legend Oscar De La Hoya, who was eliminated during Shrek Night.
Ant: Eliminated Week 3
The songstress under the bug mask turned out to be former Danity Kane member Aubrey O’Day.
Bat: Eliminated Week 4
Bat was none other than Vanderpump Rules‘ one-hit wonder Scheana Shay.
Space Ranger: Eliminated Week 5
The hip-hop icon behind the other-worldly costume was Flavor Flav.
Griffin: Eliminated Week 6
The avian character was none other than Dawson’s Creek star James Van Der Beek, who was eliminated during the Group B Finals.
Cherry Blossom: Eliminated Week 7
Full House alum Candace Cameron Bure was unmasked as the star behind the bloom after the Group C debut.
Stud Muffin: Eliminated Week 8
The studly snack was none other than hip-hop legend Method Man.
Yorkie: Eliminated Week 9
It’s “XXPEN$IVE” to be Yorkie! That’s because it was Real Housewives of Beverly Hills star and pop music icon Erika Jayne behind the furry costume.
Paparazzo: Eliminated Week 10
Say “cheese!” The man behind the Paparazzo getup was former ’90s teen heartthrob and star of hits like Boy Meets World and Mrs. DoubtfireMatthew Lawrence.
Nessy: Eliminated Week 11
The creature from Loch Ness turned out to be singer Edwin McCain.
Lucky Duck: Surprise Twist
During the semi-finals on April 30, Lucky Duck shocked fans by interrupting the competition to announce none of the final four contestants were being eliminated and all would compete for the season 13 title.
As for who was behind the feathered frock? None other than Oscar-winning filmmaker Taika Waititi, who just so happens to be married to Masked Singer judge Rita Ora!
Boogie Woogie: Finalist
Boogie Woogie made it to the finale but didn’t take home the season 13 trophy.
Behind the groovy costume was singer Andy Grammer.
Coral: Finalist
Zombies actress Meg Donnelly was unmasked as season 13’s Coral.
Mad Scientist: Finalist
Former Florida Georgia Line band member Brian Kelley was revealed to be Mad Scientist.
Pearl: Winner
Say hello to The Masked Singer‘s season 13 winner.
Country star Gretchen Wilson came out on top during the May 7 finale.
(E! and Bravo are both part of the NBCUniversal family)
